What I tell my non-American friends about Trump - MarketWatch

2017-04-15 16:54:08 by RoOz
News Business Finance Jennifer Garner 

CAMBRIDGE, Mass. ( Project Syndicate ) — I frequently travel overseas, and invariably my foreign friends ask, with varying degrees of bewilderment: What in the world is going on in your country? Here is what I say. First, do not misinterpret the 2016 election. Contrary to some commentary, the American political system has not been swept away by a wave of populism. True, we have a long history of rebelling against elites. Donald Trump tapped into a tradition associated with leaders like Andrew Jackson and William Jennings Bryan in the 19th century and Huey Long and George Wallace in the 20th century. And yet Trump lost the popular vote by nearly three million. He won the election by appealing to populist resentment in three Rust Belt states — Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin — that had previously voted Democratic. If 100,000 votes had been cast differently in those states, Trump would have lost the Electoral College and the presidency. That said, Trump’s victory points to a real problem of growing social and regional inequality in the United States. J.D. Vance’s recent best-selling book “Hillbilly Elegy” compellingly describes the vast difference between California and Appalachia. Three Things to Watch For in Tillerson's Russia Visit (2:13) U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson meets this week with his Russian counterpart, Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov. WSJ's Gerald F. Seib says there are three contentious subjects to watch for: Syria, NATO and Ukraine. Photo: Getty Research by the Princeton economists Anne Case and Angus Deaton shows that the demographic trends among lower-income whites without a college degree are worse than those for African-Americans, who historically anchored the lower extremes of inequality. In 1999, mortality rates among whites with no college were around 30% lower than those of African-Americans; by 2015, they were 30% higher. Moreover, manufacturing employment, once a prime source of high-paying jobs for working-class whites, has fallen sharply over the last generation, to just 12% of the workforce. These previously Democratic voters were attracted by Trump’s promises to shake things up and bring back manufacturing jobs. Ironically, Trump’s efforts to repeal President Barack Obama’s health-care legislation would make their lives worse. What Is the Most Dangerous Situation Trump Faces? (1:54) What is the most dangerous international situation President Trump faces? Amid many threats flaring up around the world, WSJ's Gerald F. Seib explains why North Korea, not Syria, should be on top of the list. Photo: Getty The second thing I tell my foreign friends is not to underestimate Trump’s communications skills. Many are offended by his tweet storms and outrageous disregard for facts. But Trump is a veteran of reality television, where he learned that the key to success is to monopolize viewers’ attention, and that the way to do that is with extreme statements, not careful regard for the truth. Twitter helps him to set the agenda and distract his critics. What offends commentators in the media and academia does not bother his supporters. But as he turns from his permanent self-centered campaigning to trying to govern, Twitter becomes a two-edged sword that deters needed allies. Third, I tell my friends not to expect normal behavior. Normally, a president who loses the popular vote moves to the political center to attract additional support. This is what George W. Bush did successfully in 2001. Trump, by contrasts, proclaims that he won the popular vote and, acting as though he really did, appeals to his base voters. While Trump has made solid centrist appointments to the Departments of Defense, State, and Homeland Security, his picks for the Environmental Protection Agency and the Department of Health and Human Services are from the extremes of the Republican Party. His White House staff is divided between pragmatists and ideologues, and he caters to both. Fourth, no one should underestimate U.S. institutions. Sometimes my friends talk as though the sky is falling and ask if Trump is as dangerous a narcissist as Mussolini. I tell them not to panic. The US, for all its problems, is not Italy in 1922. Our national political elites are often polarized; but so were America’s founders. In designing the U.S. Constitution, the founders’ goal was not to ensure harmonious government, but to constrain political power with a system of checks and balances that made it difficult to exercise. The joke goes that the founders created a political system that made it impossible for King George to rule over us — or for anyone to ever do so. Inefficiency was placed in the service of liberty. It is still early in the Trump presidency, and we cannot be sure what might happen after, say, a major terrorist attack. So far, however, the courts, the Congress, and the states have checked and balanced the administration, as Madison intended. And the permanent civil servants in the executive departments add ballast. Finally, my friends ask what all of this means for American foreign policy and the liberal international order led by the U.S. since 1945. Frankly, I don’t know, but I worry less about the rise of China than the rise of Trump. While American leaders, including Obama, have complained about free riders, the U.S. has long taken the lead in providing key global public goods: security, a stable international reserve currency, relatively open markets, and stewardship of the Earth’s commons. Despite the U.S.-led international order’s problems, the world has prospered and poverty has been reduced under it. But one cannot be sure it will continue. The U.S. will need to cooperate with China, Europe, Japan, and others to manage transnational problems. During the 2016 campaign, Trump was the first major party candidate in 70 years to call the American alliance system into question. Since taking office in January, statements by Trump and his appointees suggest that it is likely to persist. American hard and soft power, after all, stems largely from the fact that the U.S. has 60 allies (while China has only a few). But the stability of the multilateral institutions that help manage the world economy and global commons is more uncertain. Trump’s budget director speaks of a hard-power budget, with funds cut from the State Department and the United Nations system. Other officials advocate replacing multilateral trade deals with “fair and balanced” bilateral arrangements. And Trump is repudiating Obama’s efforts to address climate change. I tell my friends I wish I could reassure them on these issues. But I cannot. This article has been published with the permission of Project Syndicate — What I Tell My Non-American Friends. More from MarketWatch Flights to Europe Heavily Discounted This Summer Syria Strike: Sparking a Dangerous U.S.-Russia Clash? Apple loses top spot on Laptop Magazine’s best brands ranking for 2017 Related Topics Economics U.S. Economy Markets Europe U.S. Politics

Similar news on News

White House: Supreme Court choice could be announced Monday

2017-02-01 13:16:04
WASHINGTON (AP) -- A White House official says President Donald Trump could announce his pick for the Supreme Court as early as Monday. Trump originally said the announcement would come on...

Trump Set to Make His Supreme Court Pick

2017-02-01 13:16:05
WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump has settled on his first Supreme Court nominee and is poised to reveal his selection early this week, two officials say, in an announcement that many inside...

Trump to name Supreme Court nominee this week

2017-02-01 13:16:07
Trump to name Supreme Court nominee this week Jan. 29, 2017 SEND PDF WASHINGTON – The fight over filling the Supreme Court escalates this week when President Donald Trump announces his nominee...

President Donald Trump poised to reveal his selection for Supreme Court early this week

2017-02-01 13:16:08
President Donald Trump has settled on his first Supreme Court nominee and is poised to reveal his selection early this week, two officials say, in an announcement that many inside the White House...

Trump set to make his Supreme Court pick as part of a frenetic Week 2

2017-02-01 13:16:08
Trump set to make his Supreme Court pick as part of a frenetic Week 2 By Jeff Zeleny and Dan Merica, CNN Updated 0031 GMT (0831 HKT) January 30, 2017 Chat with us in Facebook Messenger. Find out...

Similar news on Business

Apps Make Pestering Congress So Easy That It Can't Keep Up | WIRED

2017-02-01 13:16:10
Apps Make Pestering Congress So Easy That It Can't Keep Up subscribe 6 months for $5 - plus a FREE Portable Phone Charger. Author: Klint Finley. Klint Finley Business Date of Publication: 01.29.17....

Scalia's Replacement Won't Be Quite So Originalist - Bloomberg View

2017-02-01 13:16:20
Law Scalia's Replacement Won't Be Quite So Originalist Noah Feldman is a Bloomberg View columnist. He is a professor of constitutional and international law at Harvard University and was a clerk to...

Judge Gorsuch: A Dream Pick for Supreme Court?

2017-02-01 13:16:22
Judge Gorsuch: A Dream Pick for Supreme Court? 01-29-2017 Paul Strand WASHINGTON--The U.S. Supreme Court has been one justice short for almost a year now after the death of Antonin Scalia last...

Google honors sculptor Edmonia Lewis with new Doodle

2017-02-01 13:16:27
Feb. 1 (UPI) -- Google is celebrating the life and career of notable African American and Native American sculptor Edmonia Lewis with a new Doodle. Google's homepage features artwork depicting...

Google Doodle For Edmonia Lewis For National Freedom Day

2017-02-01 13:38:18
Prev Story Next Story Today on the Google home page is a Doodle, special Google logo, with Edmonia Lewis on it. There is really nothing specific to February 1st and Edmonia Lewis, she was not born...

Similar news on Finance

Indian IT sector braces for impact of Donald Trump's immigration order

2017-02-01 16:02:57
Indian IT sector braces for impact of Donald Trump's immigration order Indian IT is keenly watching for Trump's directions on H1-B visa norms January 29, 2017 Last Updated at 21:56 IST email this...

Apple, Intel Lead 6 Dow Stocks In Buy Range Now

2017-02-01 16:03:39
News Apple, Intel Lead 6 Dow Stocks In Buy Range Now Apple, which reports earnings on Tuesday, is one of six Dow industrials stocks that are in buy range right now. (Apple) Reprints The Dow Jones...

Barron’s Calls For Dow 30K Already

2017-02-01 16:03:41
January 29, 2017 at 07:15 AM EST Barron’s Calls For Dow 30K Already From Tyler Durden : The financial magazine which has made an art out of calling for big, round numbers in the Dow Jones...

Magic Recipe Roundup For 1/29/2017

2017-02-01 16:03:46
January 29, 2017 at 09:27 AM EST Magic Recipe Roundup For 1/29/2017 It was a relatively quiet week for turnover in the Magic Recipe Spell , with only 2 stocks trading places and 2 10% movers, both...

How Skyworks Solutions Inc Is Growing Beyond Apple

2017-02-01 16:03:48
Image source: Skyworks Solutions. Skyworks Solutions (NASDAQ: SWKS) investors couldn't have asked for a better start to its fiscal 2017. A first quarter earnings beat and a stronger outlook for the...

Similar news on Jennifer

Discussion - List the spinoffs YOU want to see! | Page 48

2017-04-15 11:00:16
If a movie villain ever gets his own film, I would much prefer one about Grievious instead of Vader/Boba Fett/Palpatine, etc. With the old EU wiped away, Grievous pre-TCW days are really open to...

Magic Space Wizard [Star Wars: SI] Rewrite 6

2017-04-15 11:00:32
NuclearIcecream said: ↑ Something ive always wondered about the stun setting is that it seems to shoot this sort of circular wave blast thing, so would a lightsaber actually be able to deflect...

'Spider-Man' Star Tom Holland Admits He's Never Seen 'Empire Strikes Back'

2017-04-15 11:00:55
Huh. Crazy that he's seen them all but the OT. Good thing that Peter's never been a Star Wars junkie.

Exclusive: Guillermo del Toro on ‘Trollhunters’ Season 2 Plans, If He’d Direct a ‘Star Wars’ Movie

2017-04-15 11:01:25
Last week, Collider was lucky enough to host Guillermo del Toro for a sprawling half-hour interview hosted by none other than the lovely Perri Nemiroff as part of our horror-centric series Collider...

World Health Organization chief candidates Sania Nishtar, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, and David Nabarro face different treatment — Quartz

2017-04-15 11:01:51
Language April 11, 2017 The World Health Organization (WHO) is about to choose a new director general, who will be elected in May by member states. That person will run one of the United...

Similar news on Garner

Discussion - List the spinoffs YOU want to see! | Page 48

2017-04-15 11:00:16
If a movie villain ever gets his own film, I would much prefer one about Grievious instead of Vader/Boba Fett/Palpatine, etc. With the old EU wiped away, Grievous pre-TCW days are really open to...

Magic Space Wizard [Star Wars: SI] Rewrite 6

2017-04-15 11:00:32
NuclearIcecream said: ↑ Something ive always wondered about the stun setting is that it seems to shoot this sort of circular wave blast thing, so would a lightsaber actually be able to deflect...

'Spider-Man' Star Tom Holland Admits He's Never Seen 'Empire Strikes Back'

2017-04-15 11:00:55
Huh. Crazy that he's seen them all but the OT. Good thing that Peter's never been a Star Wars junkie.

Exclusive: Guillermo del Toro on ‘Trollhunters’ Season 2 Plans, If He’d Direct a ‘Star Wars’ Movie

2017-04-15 11:01:25
Last week, Collider was lucky enough to host Guillermo del Toro for a sprawling half-hour interview hosted by none other than the lovely Perri Nemiroff as part of our horror-centric series Collider...

World Health Organization chief candidates Sania Nishtar, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, and David Nabarro face different treatment — Quartz

2017-04-15 11:01:51
Language April 11, 2017 The World Health Organization (WHO) is about to choose a new director general, who will be elected in May by member states. That person will run one of the United...